|
Intervention
for Children with Developmental Coordination Disorder: A Systematic
Review
|
Susan
Hillier, PhD
Senior Lecturer, School of Health Sciences
University of South Australia
Australia
Citation:
Hillier, S. Intervention for children with developmental coordination
disorder: A systematic review. The Internet Journal of Allied Health
Sciences and Practice. July 2007, Volume 5 Number 3.
|
Abstract
Prevalence of children with
developmental coordination disorder (DCD) is high (6-13% of all school
children) and the negative impact of their movement difficulties on
their participation in recreation and academic pursuits is well
documented. This secondary research systematically reviewed the
available literature for evidence of effectiveness of interventions
that aim to improve the movement capability of children with DCD.
Specified databases were searched for appropriate studies, these were
retrieved and two reviewers appraised the level and quality of
evidence. Thirty one studies were included between levels I and III-3
of the NH & MRC protocol. Scoring using an established critical
appraisal tool demonstrated variable quality. Meta-analysis was not
possible due to the clinical heterogeneity of the primary studies. A
best evidence synthesis of results was conducted, producing clear
evidence that no intervention has poor results when compared to any
intervention. The high number of purportedly different interventions
and variable quality make definitive conclusions about the merits of
specific approaches difficult. There may be generic qualities or
factors in the studied interventions that are more important for
effectiveness than specific content. More information is needed on the
underlying mechanisms of DCD, factors influencing effectiveness and
the broader pragmatics of intervention delivery. |
|
Keywords
and terms:
Developmental coordination disorder, intervention, systematic review,
children |
|